Amy Chua’s new memoir about raising her two daughters The Battle Hymn of the Tiger Mother burst onto the scene this week in a big way, with the excerpt posted in the Wall Street Journal, under the headline “Why Chinese Mothers Are Superior.” Even if she didn’t write that provocative headline, Amy Chua’s strong words evoked a strong response, creating an instant media firestorm (and selling a lot of books):
A lot of people wonder how Chinese parents raise such stereotypically successful kids. They wonder what these parents do to produce so many math whizzes and music prodigies, what it’s like inside the family, and whether they could do it too. Well, I can tell them, because I’ve done it. Here are some things my daughters, Sophia and Louisa [Lulu], were never allowed to do:
• attend a sleepover
• have a playdate
• be in a school play
• complain about not being in a school play
• watch TV or play computer games
• choose their own extracurricular activities
• get any grade less than an A
• not be the No. 1 student in every subject except gym and drama
• play any instrument other than the piano or violin
• not play the piano or violin.
I’m using the term “Chinese mother” loosely. I know some Korean, Indian, Jamaican, Irish and Ghanaian parents who qualify too. Conversely, I know some mothers of Chinese heritage, almost always born in the West, who are not Chinese mothers, by choice or otherwise. I’m also using the term “Western parents” loosely. Western parents come in all varieties.
The manifesto struck many as completely serious and uncompromising, yet when Chua herself appeared on The Diane Rehm Show yesterday she tried to backpedal significantly, insisting that her writing is intended partly tongue-in-cheek. When a radio listener called in, clearly shaken by her own perfectionist upbringing, Chua assured her that she really did love her daughters for who they are and did not demand perfection. Chua did a mixed dance of standing by her words and back-tracking, with backing down seeming to win the day during that interview.
As “Mojo Mom” I try hard not to inflame “Mommy Wars” of any kind and I think I have a good track record on that principle over the years. I also I realize that there are many ways to be a good parent. But I assigned myself the task of actually reading Chua’s book and forcing myself to come down on one side or another: Do I think that it’s is acceptable to treat your children the way Chua raised her daughters?
My answer is, no, it’s not okay. If the behavior described in Battle Hymn of the Tiger Mother is not abusive perfectionism, what is?
Chua exerts utter control over her daughters’ lives for years. Her older daughter Sophia is signed up for piano and then Lulu is assigned the violin. During their intensive music training, Chua stands over them, gives measure-by-measure coaching and pages of notes. She makes them play for hours every day–“it’s only six hours when you waste five of them,”–practicing even on vacations where it’s a major headache to find a piano for Sophia, and taking the family away from actually seeing the places they are visiting.
When daughter Sophia plays a piano solo at Carnegie Hall at age 14, Chua is disappointed that her daughter is not playing in the main hall. (!) Chua wonders if the family dogs can be overachievers as well and has a hard time accepting that they might not live up to their full canine potential.
Along the way Chua demands utter perfection, coerces, battles with and regularly demeans her daughters, telling them they are awful and would shame her if they faltered the slightest bit. “If they next time’s not perfect I’m going to TAKE ALL YOUR STUFFED ANIMALS AND BURN THEM,” she yells during one piano practice. And, near the end of the story, when Amy has supposedly mellowed and become more enlightened, she tells Sophia before playing at their home for a group of visiting judges, “Don’t blow this. Everything turns on your performance. These justices aren’t coming to New Haven to hear a high school talent show. If you’re not over-the-top perfect we’ll have insulted them.”
Chua compels Lulu to play at her Bat Mitzvah [Chua's husband is Jewish so the girls share both heritages] when she doesn’t want to—a rite of passage that I believe should have truly been Lulu’s choice to play at. Even Chua’s own strict mother says she’s being too hard on Lulu, saying “Every child is different. You have to adjust, Amy. Look what happened to your father,” who ended up estranged from his own parents. That is perhaps Chua’s biggest failure, that she did not take into account how her approach was affecting each individual child.
Two days after the Bat Mitzvah, the family flies to Moscow and Lulu has her climactic showdown with her mother, a dramatic, public screaming match. Chua finally allows her daughter to quit the intensive violin schedule she has mandated from the age of six.
The family’s story is still unfolding, as this book was written during 2009, and Lulu stopped playing violin so intensively only recently to take up tennis. While that is portrayed as a positive step forward in her freedom, Chua can’t contain herself from trying to take that over too. She resorts to “espionage and guerilla warfare. I secretly plant ideas in her tennis coach’s head, texting her with questions and practice strategies, then deleting the text messages so Lulu won’t see them.” That’s where they are at the end of the book so it remains to be seen where they go next as the girls continue progressing through their teenage years.
One of the most interesting insights in the book was almost a throwaway comment by Chua, saying that she had tried playing tennis herself and “as an adult, I tried a few tournaments but quickly found that I couldn’t stand the pressure of competition.” I find it interesting that she would not push herself in that competitive arena the way she pushed her daughters and that she would allow herself to try something for a little while and allow herself the luxury of the judgment that it was not a rewarding activity for her. At what point to we allow our children that judgment call, too?
Do I believe that most American parents, including myself, can be too lenient? Yes. I realize there is a vast middle ground between too lenient and the extreme strictness and control that Chua imposed on her daughters. I also acknowledge that I don’t understand the immigrant experience and how that would shape and imprint someone’s world view. But Chua’s strictness is not in service of utter survival the way her parents experienced as new immigrants—they were so poor that they could not afford heat in the winter after moving to Harvard. Chua is trying to guard against “generational decline,” by being determined “not to raise a soft, entitled child—not to let my family fall.” In the process she goes way too far, molding her daughters like clay, and taking over their lives, truly overstepping the girls’ boundaries in a way that is unacceptable in American society.
I do take away one nugget of core wisdom that I can support, that kids are stronger than we often give them credit for. In the end I hope that writing this book is part of a helpful, healing journey for Amy Chua’s family and that she and her husband remain open to learning along the way.
I posted a brief review Amazon review of Battle Hymn of the Tiger Mother. I was not sure how to even think about one-to-five “stars” so I am glad to be able to do my full analysis here on the Mojo Mom Blog.
Here is a moving blog post: Dear Asian America: Forget Chua’s Book, This is Our “It Gets Better” Moment
Schedule an interview: Dr. Amy Tiemann is a frequent guest expert on parenting websites, national radio tours, magazines from Redbook to Glamour, and TV including ABC News, the CBS Early Show, and NBC’s Today Show. To schedule an interview, please contact her publicist Jill Dykes, jill (at) jilldykespr.com or (919) 749-8488
I’m going to be a guest on Lifestyle Mom Radio Cafe today, interviewed by host Dana Hilmer. The show airs live at 1 pm Eastern/10 am Pacific. The first guest will be financial expert Jean Chatzky (whom I love!) and the I’ll come on around 1:25 pm.
You can listen in live online to LA Talk Radio–we’re on channel 2. You can even call in to chat with us, (818) 602-4929 or send an email with a question for Dana to ask me or Jean Chatzky: email@example.com
Here’s a preview of today’s show:
Own Your Money Life and to Let Go (Just a bit!) for the Sake of Raising Confident Kids
Today’s guests, Jean Chatzky and Amy Tiemann are sure to spark some really smart conversation that will spur you to take control of both your financial and parenting lives. Our first guest, TODAY Show Financial Editor Jean Chatzky will be sharing with us some of things you should consider, financially speaking, when deciding to work versus stay home with the kids, the benefits and possible pitfalls to working from home, and getting out of your own way so you can make money, not excuses. Amy Tiemann, the Mojo Mom (love that name!), will be chatting with us today about how we parents need to rise to the challenge of being courageous so that we can successfully raise confident kids. We hope you join us!
Jean Chatzky is the financial editor of NBC’s TODAY Show and is known by millions for her incredible ability to make difficult financial subjects understandable to everyday people. Jean hosts her own show on Oprah radio, she is a featured columnist for More magazine and the New York Daily News and she is the author of numerous books, the most recent being Money 911: Your Most Pressing Money Questions Answered, Your Money Emergencies Solved. She is also the author of Pay it Down, Make Money Not Excuses (specifically targeting we women!) and The Difference, the focus of which is to help people thrive in a tough economy. For more information go to www.JeanChatzky.com.
Amy Tiemann, Ph.D. is a multimedia publisher, educator, and catalyst for social change. She is the celebrated author of Mojo Mom and founder of MojoMom.com. Tiemann reaches a global audience through her books, articles, podcasts, national radio tours and TV appearances, including NBC’s TODAY Show. She collaborates with the contributors to the new book, Courageous Parents, Confident Kids, to lead the way to a new era of empowered parenting, based on creativity, connection, and action.
About The LifestyleMom Radio Café
The LifestyleMom Radio Café is an internet talk radio show for women who crave information, inspiration and lively girlfriend-to- girlfriend conversation about the topics that matter to them most. Host Dana Hilmer serves up a delicious blend of entertaining and thought-provoking banter with some of today’s most inspiring women. Pull up a chair, pour yourself a fresh cup and enjoy!
Tuesdays 10:00 AM PST (1:00 PM EST)
Listen to Podcast at Your Convenience
Join the Conversation
Call-in during the show and chat with us
If you cannot call-in please feel free to submit a question for the guest and it will be asked on the show. Email your question to firstname.lastname@example.org
We hope you can join us!